Contestants:
Stephanie, Boxer
Sharron, Plus-size model
Jesse, Dresses as Elmo for Kids' Parties
From the audience: Blake, Educational rapper

Mystery Guest: Jonathan Ames

photo by Dale Harris

Contestants:
Kat, Sign language interpreter
Greg, Bike messenger
Susan, Harvests organs
From the audience: Sperra, Sleep lab technologist

Mystery Guest: Martha Plimpton

photo by Precious Little

Contestants:
Christina, Hooters Girl
Michael, Marionette puppeteer
Blaine, Sells Halloween costumes
From the audience: Julie, "Chick Lit" author

Mystery Guest: Michael Musto

photo by Nasty Canasta

Contestants:
Jasmina, Librarian
Melisa, makes fetish clothing
From the audience: Lydia, Prostitute
From the audience: Russell, Church vocal soloist

Mystery Guests: the Trachtenburg Family Slideshow Players

Photo by Megan Ghiroli

Contestants:
Chuch, Tattoo artist
Shari, Psychotherapist
Julie, Hair stylis
From the audience: Kristen, Public relations

Mystery Guest: Jo "Boobs" Weldon

Photo by Megan Ghiroli

Contestants:
Justin, Voice-over artist
Mistress Harlequinn, Dominatrix
From the audience: Mark, Edgar Allen Poe Cottage caretaker
From the audience: Julia, Babysitter

Mystery Guest: Zach Galifianakis

Photo by Dale Harris

Contestants:
Lisa, Massage therapist
Emily, Sells vintage clothes online
From the audience, Andrea, lactation consultant

Mystery Guest: Randy Jones

Photo by GiGi La Femme

Contestants:
Bruce, Manages children's theater
Robert, Comic book artist
My first line: Nasty Canasta, colonial museum reenactor

Mystery Guest: Todd Barry

Photo by Kenny Law

Contestants:
Lex, Stem Cell Researcher
Renee, Teaches Motorcycling
Bruce, Owns auto repair shop
From the audience: Jennifer, Feminist Media Analyst

Mystery Guest: Nick Kroll

Photo by Roja Rouge

Contestants:
Allyson, bubblegum card designer
Bob, Map Editor
From the audience: Rob, my first line: cake decorator

Mystery Guest: Christian Finnegan

Photo by Nasty Canasta

Contestants:
Michele, Labor Union Negotiator
Larry, Lawyer
From the audience: Paul, Jiu Jitsu Instructor

Mystery Guest: Kate Valentine

Photo by Anita Cookie

Contestants:
Special guest: Tigger! my first line: telephone survey taker
Special guest: Corn Mo, my first line: worked a tobacco farm
From the audience: Erin, my first line: ice skating coach

Mystery Guest: Annie Parisse

Photo by Precious Little

Host Neil O'Fortune and panelist Jonny Porkpie switch places!

Contestants:
John, wine maker
Ezra, spammer
From the audience: Porno Jim, adult film director

Mystery Guest: Ruby the Wonder Dog (with her partner Albert Cadabra)

Photo by Nasty Canasta

Contestants:
Perry, Baseball Umpire
Michael, The Official Manhattan Borough Historian
From the audience: Theodora, Wedding invitation designer

Mystery Guest: Debbie Rochon

Photo by Roja Rouge

Contestants:
Lauren, Forensic Scientist
Stephanie, Autopsy Photographer
From the audience: Ariel, my first line: video store manager

Mystery Guest: Aasif Mandvi

Photo by Precious Little

Contestants:
James, Dentist
Dan, Clown Instructor
From the audience: Jennifer, Private Chef

Mystery Guest: Santa Claus

Photos by Precious Little

Contestants:
Dan, Crisis Counselor
From the audience: Mac, Sommelier
From the audience: Nick, worked the driver-thru at Taco Bell

Mystery guest: Mo Rocca

Photo by Nasty Canasta